Thursday, May 1, 2008

Readings for 1,2 May & comments

The Bible readings for Thursday 1 and Friday 2 May are -- Ezra 3:1-5:17; Ps 95:1-11; Prov 19:28-29; Rom 5:1-21.
For list of 2008 readings, see first line of "Best Posts" in column at right.
Comments welcome.
1 anonymous comment with questions about Esther.
Reply to above from John.
1 other anonymous comment about making money from the site deleted.

2 Comments:

At May 26, 2008 at 11:27 AM , Anonymous Anonymous said...

Just a few random reflections on Pastor John’s sermon on Esther for the blog:

• Dating is around the 350’s BC (correct?), would this place it a short while after the time of Ezra? So that would mean the captivity was well and truly finished, the Persians the new superpower, the Greeks a “clear and present danger” and we are very close to the “inter-testament gap”.

• Some “scholars” have questioned the historicity of the story, given that it can’t be corroborated by Persian history (say some) however a strong historical credence is usually given to the “Feast of Purim” and other Jewish historical festivals.

• The Jews seemed to have had a close shave with genocide, in Persia at least, but didn’t the bulk of them go back to Judah from Babylon at the time of Ezra? i.e. the opposite direction from Persia? They had been in Babylon for a long time, I always though it was a bit hard of Ezra telling them they had to ditch their Babylonian wives.

• What was the purpose of saving the Jewish nation? – they didn’t exactly distinguish themselves 380 years later and the Romans eventually sent them packing for the next almost 2,000 years. I suppose the obvious answer is to preserve the lineage to Christ(?). They tried to patience of God to the limit 1,000 years before in the wilderness and he’s still bailing them out and in the 1st century giving them many extra decades before the destruction of the temple. It’s ironic that they were the ones who started the temple fire.

• Who wrote Esther?

 
At January 28, 2009 at 3:31 PM , Blogger Ps John said...

Some interesting comments and questions. Thanks.
The events took place in the Persian capital during a year in the reign of Ahasuerus (486-465 BC) We usually refer to him as Xerxes, the Greek spelling of his name. That's a generation before the events recorded in Ezra-Nehemiah. My RSV Harper Study Bible says this in a brief summary at the beginning of Esther. "The Persian atmosphere argues for a date not later than the conquest of the Persian Empire by Alexander the Great (331 BC)... In all probability the author was an unknown Jew who lived in Persia and had access to oral and written sources."
Your suggestion that the reason for saving the Jewish nation was to preserve the lineage of Christ is a good one and at least part of the answer. God's faithfulness to His Covenant with Israel and His Covenant promises to them is also part of the picture. This includes his plan to bless all nations through this His chosen people.
John

 

Post a Comment

Subscribe to Post Comments [Atom]

<< Home